Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Weather Tight Weather Tight is Milwaukee's window leader. Our windows are high quality energy efficient windows that have a lifetime transferable warranty. Weather Tight offers high quality durable thermal vinyl siding that will reduce noise and energy bills. We also offer beautiful engineered wood siding. Our elegant Restorations Sliding Patio Doors have the look and feel of a classic door and the safety and security to ease your mind. Weather Tight offers a unique seamless gutter system in several attractive colors to help keep your home safe from water damage and mold.
Services
Our current owners, Todd and Tod, aren't handing off the reigns completely and sailing away into retirement tomorrow (or any time soon), however. One of the great benefits of Weather Tight becoming an employee-owned company is it still allows Todd and Tod to lead and oversee the company for years to come.
At Weather Tight, we think of our team as family. Our extended circle of 100+ includes the friendliest, most helpful people in the industry, and we've created a fun, exciting place where we actually enjoy what we do. The reason I enjoy working at Weather Tight is because it really does feel like family.
The Wisconsin Torch Awards for Ethics honor businesses that meet the highest standard of ethics and trust among their employees, customers and local communities, embodying BBB's mission to advance marketplace trust. Since 2003, BBB has honored businesses and non-profit organizations of all sizes that meet the highest standard of ethics and trust among their employees, customers and local communities, embodying BBB's mission to advance marketplace trust.This award honors service professionals who have maintained exceptional service ratings and reviews on Angi in 2021.
Weather Tight is your one-stop provider for all exterior remodeling projects-a single, superior contractor for all your replacement windows, doors, roofing, siding, gutters, and more. We've been helping homeowners make smart, attractive updates for over 35 years, and are proud to be recognized as Wisconsin's most recommended remodeling business.
Reviews (28)
Write a Review
Thomas Palaszewski
May 16, 2022
Tim Anderson and the rest of the installation team were personable, professional, and performed the work at a very high level of craftsmanship resulting in a quality installation. The entire Weathertight staff from sales to installation scheduling answered all questions and keep us up to date as the project proceeded. Excellent job by all.
Andrew Gretzinger
May 07, 2022
Weathertight was an excellent company to work with for my new storm front door and storm door. From the initial consultation, to designing our door, to the install, everything was done professionally with high quality. The added benefit of a lifetime guarantee provided peace of mind also. Extra kudos to our installer Ben, who is a true craftsmen.
Mickel Petersen
Apr 21, 2022
We had several door companies provide estimates and decided to go with Weather Tight. From start to finish a very professional, customer-oriented experience. Everyone we encountered made a point of mentioning Tod & Todd. They're real dudes that the employees actually interact with. The sales rep was friendly no pressure. He explained that, due to supply chain issues, our door could take months to deliver.

No problem, we understood. They kept us informed with weekly status update emails. When the door was delivered, they scheduled the install immediately. The two individuals who installed the door were courteous and explained what they were going to do and how they were going to do it. When they finished, the went over all the operation and maintenance details.

The door looks great, fits great and we're very happy with the overall experience. When we need windows in a couple of years, we'll definitely consider Weather Tight. Could we have gotten a door cheaper? Perhaps. But I'm willing to pay a little extra for the peace of mind that you get from high quality and a company is going to stand by its products and service. Oh, and you get a box of biscotti from Tod & Todd saying thank you. Nice touch!
Linda Hrdina
Apr 15, 2022
Over the last 5 months Weather Tight replaced all the windows and the front door in my condo. This company is amazing! The installers, Chase and Justin, are the best. The product is fantastic and every employee I came in contact with provided 5 star customer service! If you have a remodeling project in mind give Weather Tight a call - you will not be disappointed!
Monica Lamb
Apr 06, 2022
While the install tech was quite detailed and worked hard to properly install a new storm and entry (back porch) door, the quality of the actual storm door is less than we expected. We have already had a return tech to adjust the install, but it appears there is a factory error. These 2 doors (storm + entry) cost us a small fortune ($$$$$) and were exact duplicates of a prior front door install. so, we did know what we were expecting.
Evan Petrie
Mar 08, 2022
Got our patio door replaced by Weather Tight because water came in through the last one. Professional and friendly from beginning to end. Also provided a realistic time frame of when the project would likely be done. The patio door installers, Chris and Chris, were also efficient, friendly and even did a little flooring manipulation when the new patio door install required it. Would definitely recommend.
Frank T.
Feb 17, 2022
I had a new front door to my home installed on my home about 7 years ago from this Weather tight company. Ever since, my outer storm door has never fit right again, letting bugs and wind in, as the installer had to remove the storm door to put in aluminum trim in the door frame and reinstall the storm door as well as put in the new inner door. They sent some one to my home twice after complaining about it within the first year, trying to correct and seal it.

The repair man they sent out both times said there was nothing further he could do. So this winter I complained to the company again, telling them the repairman they sent was incompetent. A woman at their place got onto the phone and rudely and loudly told me they would send another repairman out to my home to fix it for $ 250.00 this time. They charged me $ 3,500. for this new inner door, and I would expect better service from them. Please beware this company!
Jeremy Swanson
Jan 11, 2022
After a great experience several years ago when we replaced all of our windows on the main floor of our house it was an easy decision to go with Weathertight again to replace out front/back exterior doors and the 2 windows in our newly finished (exposed) basement. I did not feel pressured during the sales experience and despite supply chain issues resulting in an extended wait between initial sale and installation I was kept well informed during the entire process.

The product and installation is top notch and I couldn't be happier with the final results. The installers, Ben and Chais, were very professional, courteous and willing to accommodate all of my little detailed requests with the installation.
Sarah Chojnacki
Dec 15, 2021
I would 10/10 recommend this company! My husband and I struggled for 6 months using 5 different companies that could never answers our questions, couldn't find our mysterious leaking source, and would NEVER be professional about communication. Weather Tight SAVED US! We FINALLY got our roof PROPERLY repaired, and they kept in constant communication with us throughout the whole process. They are very professional, and they are worth the price tag when it comes to the safety of your home and reliability of the quality of the work done. :
Sarah Holmquist
Dec 14, 2021
I cannot say enough about the service that we were provided by Weather Tight every step of the way! Our salesperson Andy was fantastic and answered all of our questions, the schedulers were amazing and very accommodating when we had to push back our install due to a personal issue. Our installer Chris S was great as well, he walked us through everything and cleaned up everything afterwards. He even fixed a small area of our trim that wasn't part of the original request because it was near our front door. We will 100% be using them again.
Tim Ochnikowski
May 01, 2021
We recently had Weather Tight install new entry and storm / screen doors on our home. We couldn't be more pleased with the entire process. The salesman (Mike) was upfront, honest and professional. The quality of the doors was fantastic. The installation crew of Chris and Chris were professional, informative, helpful, and friendly. It was a pleasure working with everyone. We wouldn't hesitate to use them again on another project.
Vick F.
Nov 10, 2020
Waited a long time for fire door installation. After telling the office person I was going to place a complaint on the internet regarding no date for installation yet one of owners called and told me they were going to install within 2 weeks. I was told by the salesperson when I ordered the door that weather tight did not use subcontractors. When the installer showed up at my house with his own car and trailer I asked if he was a subcontractor and he said yes.

I wasn't happy. He forgot the trim pieces and another installer had to drop them off at my house. He installed the wrong hardware and when I pointed it out to him he said you are right. The door wasn't installed correctly and to keep the door closed the installer told me to use the second lock to keep the door closed. I spoke with Eric at weather tight about these 2 issues he told me they would order the correct hardware and take a look at the install.

I have been waiting over a month and still no word from weather tight that my hardware is in or someone is going to correctly install my door. I have to slam the door shut and quickly lock the door to keep it in place. Still waiting and waiting for service and hardware
K. W.
May 18, 2020
Requested a quote from a competing company last year regarding replacement of gutters, but they unfortunately dropped the ball in working with us to get the work scheduled (never responded to emails, etc). Waited until the weather was nicer, and requested a quote from Weather Tight. The sales rep warned us jokingly before giving us the estimate to prepare ourselves that his number would be 2x whatever we were thinking.

I was thinking of the quote from the other company. Yeah. Weather Tight's quote was 2.5x higher than the previous company's quote even AFTER he applied $2k+ in discounts to our quote. Note that the $2k discount also ONLY applied if we immediately agreed and put money down today. Incredibly unabashedly inflated pricing, and high-pressure sales tactics (sorry, not sorry - saying we can only get the savings if we agree on the spot and put money down today IS high-pressure sales - a good company would understand a married couple needs time to discuss (or hell maybe get 1 more quote) and would honor any offered discounts for the next few days/until the end of the week).

You want an immediate answer without allowing us time to even discuss privately, our only option is going to be to say no. Not that we'd ever say yes to the price given to us, but on principle: you need to allow people time to discuss and make a decision without the sales rep there.
Jonathan P.
Jul 03, 2019
I feel scammed. This company charged much more than the job should have cost, but since I needed to finance the job, I went with them. I should have let the roof collapse, instead. The salesman pushed the job hard, and forgot to mention that the contract was a fixed price, after hinting that less than the 25% replacement for roof decking they padded the bill with might not have to get done. 2 months of waiting and delays later, a local contractor did the work.

I have finally finished picking nails and shingles out of the yard. In July. The job was "done" in March, when temperatures were too cold (According to the manufacturer) to install the membrane. The manager insisted it was fine, and that the roof would flatten when the sun warmed it up. Still rippled. In July. The fascia took 2 attempts to fix, and the soffit vents they installed were slapped on as an afterthought, hole sawed and screwed to the soffit with gaps and holes around them.

I fully expect my attic to be a giant wasp nest by now. After 4 tries and 2 management visits, they finally fulfilled the main points of the contract. I told them not to bother trying to clean up after the 4th try, as I wanted them off my property. Use a local roofing crew, and buy better materials. It is exactly the same service, with a huge discount.
Robert U.
May 29, 2019
The whole took great care of my home. They were very friendly and polite. They made sure I was completely satisfied, answering all of my questions and more. I was beyond pleased with the level of service, professionalism and product.
Nancy H.
Apr 04, 2019
Won't be using this service. Put in a request for re roofing job. Was answered right away. However the woman who telephoned me talked so fast almost thought she sure did not have any interest in a job. I am paying for the re roofing on a home I live in with my daughter who owns the home. They would not meet with only me and said if they had to then meet with my daughter at another time there may be additional charge for that. Well, you know this conversation was very disappointed and I sure will not tell anyone else to call them.

I will turn off all their commercials now. I live in an area where the homes are all going to need roofing in the near future. I already have 3 estimates and all of the young men who came to talk with me were very nice. Hard to decide. My residence is in Dousman.
Janet S.
Feb 06, 2019
I did read my Contract, It says "Matching Trim". White does not match dark Grey. The white is getting stained just like I said it would. I am glad you are going to replace it with a matching trim, something dark that will hide staining. My frustration is calling 3 times to talk to the owner, with no call back. I have 2 phones you can call. All I wanted to know is why a handle is 250 dollars.

When I called, you all are in meetings, sorry you have to be too busy to call me back. And yes, I called the manufacturer and they were more than happy to send me a free replacement because of the loss of finish. The Contracting business is competative, I have contractors calling me begging for business. I at least deserve a call from the owner if I have questions that the office people cannot answer.
Jeff R.
Jan 25, 2019
First thing read the full contract before signing it. I had them come to my house to give me a quote on a new metal roof well after getting the quote I decided to go with it. They wanted half the money down which I paid but then came the fun part of waiting I was given a six month window in which the work would take place which I found out later after reading the small print on the contract now the problem I was told it would happen very soon from the time of signing the contract after contacting them at least three times to find out when the work would start and never getting a strait answer.finally on the very last day before the contract would be cancelled they called to setup the work date.

Well after going through a very bad health issues and being out of work and where I could not return because of my health I could not afford it anymore. After talking to Tod or Todd not sure which one to try and cancel the job I was told I would not be able to cancel it. Well after pretty much begging him and telling him how my situation changed and about my health problems he decided to give me some of my money back but he still walked away with $4000 of my money for not doing a single thing which I had to take from my 401K.

To say the least I was not very happy. I did finally get my roof done at 1/3 the price of what they wanted by a very nice and respectful company that understood my situation and it was done within a week of contacting them. I guess you don't need to charge through the roof to get a quality job done which is the lesson today and also read the whole contract before signing so you don't get stuck in a situation like I did.

Also I wish I would of looked on yelp and looked at the reviews for there company I would not of gone with there company for anything. Hope this helps every one else out there looking for work to be done on your house.
Sammi-Jo N.
Nov 30, 2018
Great work. Received windows, siding and roof. Efficient and quality work from all the crews. Crews were also very friendly and respectful.
George W.
Jul 14, 2018
What was a bad client experience I just had. Tried to schedule an appointment for next week and I said I could only do 2 hrs they would not schedule me. I had to clear my whole afternoon or no meeting. i have kids to pick up. wow.
Wendy D.
Apr 22, 2018
They were a no call no show for estimate appointment. Chose them based on commercial as seemed hometown and caring. Very deceiving. Forgot to check yelp. Big mistake. We already were skeptical based on the phone call to set up the estimate appointment. The lady who answered the phone was very airheaded. Asked the same questions and said the same things many times.

We needed the estimate because all of our windows were recalled and we needed to submit the estimate so the company could send them a check to get the windows replaced. The call was more like a call for a timeshare. So many questions. They said we both needed to be home, kept asking if we have other appointments that would keep us from the appointment which is odd but we made it for yesterday, Saturday.

My husband is disabled, our dog just had surgery, and this was the first weekend I had off in a month. I didn't want to get up early but we needed to get this done. We got up super early so we could get all the dogs down to the basement living room and clear out the areas around the windows for them. We waited and waited and they were a no show, no call.

We don't live in an expensive neighborhood but a nice one on the southeast side not that that should matter to them as people from all over need window work. We did not call them after waiting 2 hours to ask where they were because that is very bad service and we were already skeptical and had a bad vibe about the company based on our initial phone call to set up the appt. it would have been an easy sell for them.
Amy Z.
Feb 06, 2018
We contacted Weather Tight in early 2017 looking for a total tear-off and new roof. We were given an estimate window of 4:30ish in early February which I thought was odd because most of the roofers we had to our home wanted to come during the day, and definitely well before dusk, to see how our current roof looked. The two gentlemen came to our home, much as I imagined, as it was starting to get dark.

They came in to give us the sales pitch as the sun was setting. There was a lot of talking and while I don't mind some small talk and getting to know someone, when time and sunlight is of the essence, it seemed strange. At one point I looked at the main salesman and asked if they were going to take a look at our roof and he looks out our windows and says "Well it's pretty dark." You think.

The two gentlemen went outside with their iPhone flashlights on and tried to get a good idea of the shape of our roof. Then they came in and went into our attic to examine some more. At this point they had been with us for about an hour and a half and we had plans with my folks that night which I repeatedly mentioned. They sat back down at our table and took out a computer with a lengthy powerpoint at which point I asked how much longer this would take.

The main salesman acted astonished that on a Monday evening I may have something else to do (maybe eat dinner?) and said there was a lot to go over still. At that point my husband stepped in and asked for the estimate and some literature about their products. We were given a nicely printed folder of information and were informed that the main salesman would be on vacation the next week but he would get it to us as soon as he got back.

My husband called and followed up about three times for that estimate but never heard back. Then we got another 2-3 calls asking if we had made a decision about the proposal (from some man in their office) that we never received. My husband told that man during each call we hadn't received the estimate and he also promised it. I have to say this was by the far the strangest service call I've had from any home improvement company and we've had numerous people stop out as we bought a fixer-upper.

My husband jokes that come spring when we get our annual Weather Tight sales pitch at our door that he'll ask where his estimate is even though we've long since put a new roof on and were very pleased with that company.
Alex A.
Aug 07, 2017
Looking to replace 6 windows on our house. Had 4 different companies (they are all claiming to be the best) come in and give us estimate. Weather tight happen to be the first one and most expensive one by far. They wanted over 8K for 6 windows. Sales person was really nice but way too sales focused. We did not go with them. They dont have or show you price list, they just pull random number out of computer, it seems like.
Shawn M.
Jul 20, 2017
Way too sales focused! Over an hour of listening to a sales pitch which included everything from the sales guy acting like getting multiple estimates was a waste of time, to a high pressure close. Yes, Weathertight, simply asking a potential customer to commit on the spot, without giving the couple time to talk privately, is a high pressure sales tatic.

This was the exact company I needed to speak with to insure that the company I was thinking of hiring for my new roof wasn't the highest bid. Weathertight's price on a new roof was as much as DOUBLE compared to my other estimates. They were even higher than the one quote I got that included replacing all my roof decking. Weathertight's did not include this work.

After all this all I got was a price shown to me on a computer screen. Nothing was listed in detail as far as work to be performed and materials to be used. Literally just an incredibly inflated number, followed by a bunch of discounts, that ultimately still lead to the most expensive bid I've seen yet BY FAR (as mentioned above). And yes, I was even told they use subcontractors.

This was also the only roofing contractor I spoke with that asked me to commit on the spot. I will say though I did expect this kind of a sales approach. When setting up the estimate the lady on the phone was adamant about making sure it was at a time when both my wife and I were home. Which really was just inconvenient as I'm home all day, and when she gets home from a long day of work the last thing she wants to do is listen to drawn out sales pitch.

She wants to eat dinner. she's eating for two. This could have easily been done during the day. I will say, I legitimately feel bad for the sales guy. He was a really nice guy. He just has to perform at his job in a way that rubs people the wrong way.
Joel H.
Dec 15, 2016
The salesman over-sold the gutter system product by a moonshot. They promised one day installation but it took 6 months. Installers cancelled or didn't show 5 times. One time the installers left the job site mid-job without installing the down spouts. This caused water damage in the basement. Once the product was installed, we continued to have issues.

The manager kept telling us that we will be charged extra for services that our sales rep sold to us in the contract. For the astronomic price we paid for our gutters, we expected a solid gold gutter system that could relieve all our worries. Unfortunately just the opposite happened. The product is cheap and flimsy. We have to call to have the system fixed all the time.

Also this system causes icicles to form on your house. This is the first winter, and we have a TON of icicles. Apparently this is a known issue that gutter system companies hide in the fine print of their contracts. Which seems extremely deceptive. I think it looks awful, is dangerous, detracts away from curb appeal, and decreases property value because it appears that I don't insulate my house.

Weather Tight is the company that did ours and I would like to warn all prospective gutter system buyers about this issue. When you talk to their customer support staff they treat you like Time Warner Cable support. Just horrendous. Please read all the one star reviews on here and on Google. I never go out of my way to review companies, but I really feel I must warn people about how this company decides to do business and how they decide to treat their customers.
Richard S.
Oct 16, 2016
They started and finished on time, I believe the work to be good quality. The only issue was the estimate was low due to an error by the estimator. The cost increased by $700, with our consent. I didn't make a big deal out of it because I had a price range in mind, and we were still in that range. They did offer to void the contract, but we went ahead.
Scott D.
Aug 22, 2016
After 3 yrs of having all the windows in our house replaced at 15,000 cost they still charged us a 85. Service call fee to come look at a window which was covered in black mold due to the window not having any insulation put in when they put the window in! You could feel the cold air pour through the cracks of the moldings and yet the service tech never pulled the moulding to check it out.

He instead blamed it on a vent being closed. It wasn't until I pulled the moldings off when painting the window this spring that I noticed that there was NO insulation around the window where there should have been. You could literally see outside light come in to the room around the jamb of window plus there was a 1 void all around the window space.

Not to mention that the drywall under neath the window has now become detached due to the moisture which I had to screw back to the studs as well as re spackle around the entire window due to the crappy way it was left unfinished. I have placed several calls and showed photos to Eric Folsom at weathertight and he has yet returned my calls. There is a service apt set for September and will update this ad then.

For now I am not happy that they did this shoddy work and then charged a service fee too this is unethical business practice. I also am preparing a bill for the labor and materials I purchased to finish their work on this window which was not installed properly. Update : Eric came to the house and explained the situation re the window. The windows were installed properly, insulated, caulked, the existing gap was a result of shoddy workmanship from when the house was constructed and was not included in the initial estimate of replacing the windows Only and not replacing the interior jambs or moldings. Thanks Eric for addressing this issue in a timely manner.
Debbie A.
Sep 20, 2013
We talked to Weather Tight at the State Fair. I thought they were high pressured there, but decided to meet with them because I saw some positive reviews on them. I guess I didn't read enough of them. I have never sat through a more insulting sales presentation. It was absolutely demeaning. After 2 hours, my husband had to go to bed. The salesman had the nerve to say he had to end the appointment since we both had to be present. Hmmm - sounds like a time share presentation, right?

After that night, I read more of the reviews and found many that reflected our experience. From what I have now learned, it turns out that they pressure you to make a decision on the spot. I was honest from the beginning that I wanted information because we weren't even sure we were going to do our windows. I guess I can thank my husband for having to go to bed before we ever got to the money part.

I don't understand. If you have a good product, why do you have to stoop to slimy sales tactics. When they called back, I was very direct with my feedback. They keep calling me. So far we haven't answered, but I guess I will and tell them to leave us alone. I'll be very wary of future window salesman I invite into my home.